Skip to content
Policy & Tenders · Finance & M&A · Analysis · United States

Heat pump vs gas furnace running cost by state: the break-even efficiency

At EIA's average 2025-26 prices, a heat pump at the 7.5 HSPF2 federal minimum costs less to run than an 80% gas furnace in only 9 states, led by Florida, Arkansas and Georgia. A 9.0 HSPF2 model wins in 19. In Illinois, New York or Michigan the break-even is above HSPF2 13.

Reviewed by Pruthvi A. · 7 min read
Transmission towers and power lines on a hillside

In 50 words: At EIA's average 2025-26 prices, a heat pump at the 7.5 HSPF2 federal minimum costs less to run than an 80% gas furnace in only 9 states, led by Florida, Arkansas and Georgia. A 9.0 HSPF2 model wins in 19. In Illinois, New York or Michigan the break-even is above HSPF2 13.

Whether a heat pump is cheaper to run than a gas furnace is not a matter of opinion. It is a ratio: the price of a kWh of electricity against the price of a therm of gas, and the heat pump's efficiency against the furnace's. We worked out, for every state, the heat pump efficiency at which the two cost the same, using EIA's state prices. Run your own bills in the heat pump vs gas furnace calculator.

How the break-even works

A therm of gas holds 100,000 Btu, or 29.3 kWh. A furnace turns a share of it into heat: its AFUE rating, 80% at the federal minimum for most gas furnaces today and 95% for non-weatherized furnaces made from December 18, 2028. A heat pump delivers heat at a seasonal efficiency given by its HSPF2 rating in Btu per watt-hour; dividing by 3.412 gives the coefficient of performance (COP). The federal minimum for split systems is HSPF2 7.5, a COP of about 2.2.

The break-even HSPF2 is the rating at which the heat pump's electricity costs exactly what the furnace's gas costs for the same heat:

break-even HSPF2 = 3.412 x 29.3 x AFUE x electricity price per kWh / gas price per therm

It does not depend on how much heat the home needs, only on prices and the furnace. At the US average (18.19 cents per kWh, $1.48 per therm), it is about 9.8 against an 80% furnace.

Break-even by state

Electricity is EIA's 2026 year-to-date average residential price; gas is EIA's 2025 average residential price, converted at EIA's 1,036 Btu per cubic foot. The last column is the yearly running cost saving of an HSPF2 9.0 heat pump over an 80% furnace, for the gas a typical gas-heated home in that state used for space heating in EIA's 2020 survey (negative means the heat pump costs more). Sorted from the most to the least favourable state for heat pumps.

StateElectricity (¢/kWh)Gas ($/therm)Break-even HSPF2 vs 80% furnacevs 95% furnaceYearly saving at HSPF2 9.0 vs 80% furnace
Florida15.322.465.05.9$93
Arkansas13.741.865.97.0$283
Georgia15.481.976.37.5$220
Louisiana13.271.686.37.5$104
Washington14.421.706.88.1$194
Texas16.031.876.98.1$105
Arizona15.361.796.98.2$68
Hawaii46.415.067.38.7$420
Mississippi15.061.617.58.9$93
North Carolina14.941.58*7.69.0$90
Oregon15.461.617.79.1$102
South Carolina15.901.63*7.89.3$63
Alabama16.511.697.89.3$64
Missouri14.281.447.99.4$97
Oklahoma13.811.397.99.4$69
Kentucky14.201.378.39.8$46
Virginia16.951.628.49.9$50
Nevada13.361.278.410.0$21
Kansas15.261.438.510.1$37
Delaware17.981.549.311.1-$24
West Virginia15.581.339.411.1-$33
Nebraska12.921.109.411.2-$25
Tennessee13.801.149.711.5-$38
Wyoming14.011.139.911.8-$73
Massachusetts30.192.4210.011.9-$129
Utah13.190.9810.812.8-$89
North Dakota12.460.9210.812.9-$130
Maryland21.311.56*10.913.0-$146
Vermont23.931.7411.013.1-$182
Rhode Island29.052.09*11.113.2-$316
Ohio18.811.3411.213.3-$207
Iowa14.551.0211.413.6-$155
Pennsylvania21.131.4511.713.8-$245
New Hampshire26.911.8012.014.2-$260
South Dakota14.580.9512.314.6-$185
Indiana17.041.1112.314.6-$240
California32.582.1212.314.6-$137
District of Columbia24.861.6112.414.7-$173
Minnesota16.441.0612.414.7-$257
Colorado16.801.0812.414.8-$217
New Mexico15.340.9512.915.3-$160
Montana14.130.8713.015.4-$233
Maine30.231.83*13.215.7-$423
Connecticut27.471.62*13.616.1-$401
New York29.261.7013.816.4-$416
New Jersey24.091.3714.116.7-$467
Idaho13.020.7414.116.7-$213
Illinois19.231.0914.116.8-$411
Wisconsin19.051.0414.717.4-$390
Michigan21.731.0516.619.7-$641
Alaska27.321.2517.520.8-$1,114

* No 2025 gas price in EIA's table; 2024 value used.

What the numbers show

  • Nine states favour even a minimum-efficiency heat pump. In Florida, Arkansas, Georgia, Louisiana, Washington, Texas, Arizona, Hawaii and Mississippi, the break-even is at or below HSPF2 7.5.
  • A better heat pump changes the answer in ten more. At HSPF2 9.0 the heat pump also wins in North Carolina, Oregon, South Carolina, Alabama, Missouri, Oklahoma, Kentucky, Virginia, Nevada and Kansas.
  • Cheap gas and dear electricity rule it out on running cost alone. Where gas is near $1 a therm and electricity near 20 cents, as in Illinois, Wisconsin and Michigan, the break-even is HSPF2 14 or more, far above the federal minimum of 7.5.
  • A new 95% furnace raises the bar by about a fifth. Every break-even is 19% higher against a 95% furnace than against an 80% one.

What the table leaves out

  • Average, not marginal, prices. EIA's averages include fixed charges. Your marginal gas and electricity prices, the ones that change with use, are lower, and which one falls more depends on your utility. Use your own bills in the calculator.
  • Climate. HSPF2 is rated for a moderate climate. In cold regions a heat pump's real seasonal efficiency is lower than its rating, which raises the bar further; cold-climate models narrow that gap.
  • Cooling and the gas connection. A heat pump also replaces a central air conditioner, and dropping gas entirely saves the monthly customer charge. Both can tip the decision where running costs are close.
  • Electricity rates for heat pumps. Some utilities offer lower winter or heat pump rates, which lower the break-even directly.
  • No federal credit. The IRS says the 25C credit is not allowed for property placed in service after December 31, 2025, so the up-front cost is now full price unless your state or utility offers a rebate.

Frequently asked questions

Is a heat pump cheaper to run than a gas furnace?

In nine states, even a minimum-efficiency heat pump is cheaper to run than an 80% furnace at EIA's average prices, and an HSPF2 9.0 model is cheaper in 19. Elsewhere, especially where gas costs about $1 a therm, gas stays cheaper on running cost alone.

What is a good HSPF2 for a heat pump?

One above the break-even for your prices and furnace. The federal minimum for split systems is 7.5. At the US average prices the break-even against an 80% furnace is about 9.8, and against a 95% furnace about 11.7.

Why is a heat pump more expensive to run in Illinois or Michigan?

Because gas is cheap there relative to electricity. Illinois averaged about $1.09 a therm of gas against 19.23 cents per kWh, so a heat pump needs an HSPF2 of about 14 to match an 80% furnace.

Does the break-even depend on the size of my house?

No. The break-even efficiency depends only on prices and the furnace's AFUE. The size of the saving or loss scales with how much heat your home uses.

Free toolSize a home battery and see cost and paybackOpen BESS calculator →

Sources

  1. EIA, Natural Gas Prices: residential price by state, annual (release of October 30, 2026)
  2. EIA, Electric Power Monthly, Table 5.6.B (residential, year-to-date through August 2026)
  3. EIA, Residential Energy Consumption Survey 2020, table CE4.6.NG.ST
  4. EIA, Units and calculators (1,036 Btu per cubic foot)
  5. 10 CFR 430.32 (DOE minimum HSPF2 and AFUE)
  6. IRS, FAQs on Public Law 119-21 (25C termination)
EE
About the authorEarth Energy Log Editorial DeskArticles are researched and drafted by the Earth Energy Log desk with AI assistance, checked against primary sources, and reviewed by a named editor before publication.More from Earth Energy Log Editorial Desk →

Researched and drafted by the Earth Energy Log Editorial Desk with AI assistance. Reviewed by Pruthvi A. before publication.

How we work: Editorial standards · AI disclosure · Report an error

More in Policy & Tenders

Newsletter

The weekly brief

Every Tuesday: the 5 stories that matter, India tender awards roundup, one chart we made. Free.

No spam. Unsubscribe in one click.